| Rank
| Title
| Lifetime Gross | Max Theaters | Opening | Open Th | Release Date | Distributor
|
|---|
| 1 | A League of Their Own | $107,533,928 | 2,084 | $13,739,456 | 1,782 | Jul 1, 1992 | Sony Pictures Releasing |
| 2 | 42 | $95,020,213 | 3,405 | $27,487,144 | 3,003 | Apr 12, 2013 | Warner Bros. |
| 3 | Moneyball | $75,605,492 | 3,018 | $19,501,302 | 2,993 | Sep 23, 2011 | Sony Pictures Releasing |
| 4 | The Rookie | $75,600,072 | 2,543 | $16,021,684 | 2,511 | Mar 29, 2002 | Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures |
| 5 | Field of Dreams | $64,431,625 | 1,100 | $531,346 | 22 | Apr 21, 1989 | Universal Pictures |
| 6 | The Benchwarmers | $59,843,754 | 3,282 | $19,656,429 | 3,274 | Apr 7, 2006 | Revolution Studios |
| 7 | Rookie of the Year | $53,615,089 | 1,544 | $9,122,714 | 1,460 | Jul 9, 1993 | Twentieth Century Fox |
| 8 | Bull Durham | $50,888,729 | 1,297 | $5,009,301 | 1,238 | Jun 17, 1988 | Orion Pictures |
| 9 | Angels in the Outfield | $50,236,831 | 1,921 | $8,916,463 | 1,894 | Jul 15, 1994 | Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures |
| 10 | Major League | $49,797,148 | 1,615 | $8,836,265 | 1,541 | Apr 7, 1989 | Paramount Pictures |
| 11 | The Natural | $47,951,979 | 1,012 | $5,088,381 | 989 | May 11, 1984 | TriStar Pictures |
| 12 | Fever Pitch | $42,071,069 | 3,275 | $12,400,125 | 3,267 | Apr 8, 2005 | Twentieth Century Fox |
| 13 | Hardball | $40,222,729 | 2,314 | $9,386,342 | 2,137 | Sep 14, 2001 | Paramount Pictures |
| 14 | Million Dollar Arm | $36,457,627 | 3,019 | $10,515,659 | 3,019 | May 16, 2014 | Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures |
| 15 | Trouble with the Curve | $35,763,137 | 3,212 | $12,162,040 | 3,212 | Sep 21, 2012 | Warner Bros. |
| 16 | For Love of the Game | $35,188,640 | 2,933 | $13,041,685 | 2,829 | Sep 17, 1999 | Universal Pictures |
| 17 | Bad News Bears | $32,868,349 | 3,183 | $11,382,472 | 3,183 | Jul 22, 2005 | Paramount Pictures |
| 18 | The Sandlot | $32,434,006 | 1,775 | $4,918,712 | 1,772 | Apr 9, 1993 | Twentieth Century Fox |
| 19 | Major League II | $30,626,182 | 2,167 | $7,040,777 | 2,167 | Apr 1, 1994 | Warner Bros. |
| 20 | Mr. 3000 | $21,811,187 | 2,736 | $8,679,028 | 2,736 | Sep 17, 2004 | Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures |
| 21 | Mr. Baseball | $20,883,046 | 1,866 | $5,240,375 | 1,855 | Oct 2, 1992 | Universal Pictures |
| 22 | Summer Catch | $19,753,553 | 2,335 | $7,018,593 | 2,335 | Aug 24, 2001 | Warner Bros. |
| 23 | The Fan | $18,626,419 | 2,016 | $6,271,406 | 2,016 | Aug 16, 1996 | Sony Pictures Releasing |
| 24 | The Babe | $17,530,973 | 1,568 | $5,011,205 | 1,566 | Apr 17, 1992 | Universal Pictures |
| 25 | Everyone's Hero | $14,523,101 | 2,898 | $6,061,762 | 2,896 | Sep 15, 2006 | Twentieth Century Fox |
| 26 | Little Big League | $12,267,790 | 1,606 | $3,105,618 | 1,527 | Jul 1, 1994 | Columbia Pictures |
| 27 | The Hill | $7,665,865 | 1,703 | $2,301,931 | 1,570 | Aug 25, 2023 | Briarcliff Entertainment |
| 28 | Stealing Home | $7,467,504 | 985 | $2,346,864 | 984 | Aug 26, 1988 | Warner Bros. |
| 29 | BASEketball | $7,027,290 | 1,910 | $3,086,105 | 1,905 | Jul 31, 1998 | Universal Pictures |
| 30 | Eight Men Out | $5,680,515 | 349 | $1,129,491 | 147 | Sep 2, 1988 | Orion Pictures |
| 31 | Ed | $4,422,380 | 1,583 | $1,910,840 | 1,541 | Mar 15, 1996 | Universal Pictures |
| 32 | Major League: Back to the Minors | $3,572,443 | 2,322 | $2,087,011 | 2,322 | Apr 17, 1998 | Warner Bros. |
| 33 | Home Run | $2,861,020 | 381 | $1,623,000 | 381 | Apr 19, 2013 | The Samuel Goldwyn Company |
| 34 | The Scout | $2,694,234 | 1,585 | $1,458,837 | 1,585 | Sep 30, 1994 | Twentieth Century Fox |
| 35 | The Slugger's Wife | $1,878,561 | 898 | $1,314,993 | 898 | Mar 29, 1985 | Columbia Pictures |
| 36 | The Final Season | $1,159,691 | 1,011 | $661,049 | 1,011 | Oct 12, 2007 | Yari Film Group Releasing |
| 37 | Sugar | $1,082,124 | 51 | $60,140 | 11 | Apr 3, 2009 | Sony Pictures Classics |
| 38 | The Perfect Game | $1,037,071 | 417 | $511,698 | 417 | Apr 16, 2010 | - |
| 39 | Cobb | $1,007,583 | 4 | $63,786 | 4 | Dec 2, 1994 | Warner Bros. |
| 40 | Still We Believe: The Boston Red Sox Movie | $396,803 | 54 | $91,388 | 17 | May 7, 2004 | THINKFilm |
| 41 | Talent for the Game | $336,396 | 60 | $62,571 | 60 | Apr 26, 1991 | Paramount Pictures |
| 42 | Mickey | $294,758 | 76 | $75,235 | 42 | Apr 30, 2004 | Slugger Pictures |
| 43 | This Old Cub | $270,014 | 6 | $31,252 | 6 | Mar 26, 2004 | Emerging Pictures |
| 44 | Pastime | $267,265 | 42 | $54,726 | 42 | Aug 23, 1991 | Miramax |
| 45 | Heading Home: The Tale of Team Israel | $207,533 | 7 | $12,678 | 1 | Dec 14, 2018 | Menemsha Films |
| 46 | War Eagle, Arkansas | $123,670 | 7 | $16,467 | 7 | Jun 12, 2009 | Hannover House |
| 47 | Ballplayer: Pelotero | $46,109 | 10 | $20,628 | 10 | Jul 13, 2012 | Strand Releasing |
| 48 | Home Run Showdown | $8,824 | 1 | $8,824 | 1 | Jul 27, 2012 | Image Entertainment |
| 49 | Undrafted | $5,777 | 20 | $3,829 | 20 | Jul 15, 2016 | - |
