Top-Grossing Movies That Never Hit #1, the Top 5, or Top 10

Data as of May 12, 2:00 PDT
Rank Release Total Gross Top Rank Overall Rank Year Distributor
201Of Gods and Men$35,54781,4172011-
202Chronicle$35,54481,418201220th Century Fox International
203Man Up$35,523111,4202015-
204Alvin and the Chipmunks$35,477121,4212007-
205The Reef 2: High Tide$35,12261,4252012-
206The Snow Queen 2$34,79381,4282015-
207The Island$34,72571,4302008-
208Big Miracle$34,67481,4312012United International Pictures
209The Good Lie$34,66761,4322014Jaguar Film International Distribution
210The Babymakers$34,60871,4332013-
211Escape from Planet Earth$34,35171,4352013Italian International Film
212Rob-B-Hood$34,10971,4382007-
213Winter's Tale$33,89861,4402014Warner Bros.
214Mars Needs Moms$33,80271,4412011Walt Disney Pictures
215Family For Rent$33,65891,4442015-
216Beyond a Reasonable Doubt$33,62481,4462009Italian International Film
217That Awkward Moment$33,57681,4482014-
218Baba$33,43361,4502012-
219The Book Thief$33,42281,451201420th Century Fox International
220Dorian Gray$33,36091,4522010Prime Pictures
22188 Minutes$33,34771,4532008-
222There Will Be Blood$33,30361,4542008-
223The Lark Farm$33,10771,4552008-
224Little Brother, Big Trouble: A Christmas Adventure$33,06071,4562013Italian International Film
225All Is Lost$32,97771,4572013Italian International Film
226Arthur$32,91371,4582011Warner Bros.
227The Cabin in the Woods$32,83061,4612012-
228London Boulevard$32,81261,4622011-
229Kamal Joumblatt, Witness and Martyr$32,762121,4642015-
230Barbie in Rock 'N Royals$32,759101,4652015United International Pictures
231Dallas Buyers Club$32,71281,4662014-
232Badges of Fury$32,66171,4672013Italian International Film
233Blood: The Last Vampire$32,33661,4702009Italian International Film
234The Prestige$32,203241,4712007-
2351408$32,06891,4762007-
236Woman in Gold$32,04581,4782015Italian International Film
237Midnight in Paris$31,95161,4802012-
238Carnage$31,673101,4842012-
239Her$31,625181,4872014Italian International Film
240Knocked Up$31,60461,4882007-
241Cirque du Freak: The Vampire's Assistant$31,58761,4892009United International Pictures
242Cendrillon$31,54371,4902013-
243Real Steel$31,49981,4912011Walt Disney Pictures
244Beyond the Reach$31,39061,4922015-
245The Purge$31,32081,4932013United International Pictures
246Triangle$31,195101,4952009Prime Pictures
247Machine Gun Preacher$31,136111,4962012-
248Mr. Brooks$31,07891,4972007-
249I Could Never Be Your Woman$30,93671,4992008-
250Planet 51$30,874141,5022009-
251Two Lovers$30,81371,5062009-
252Molière$30,53281,5082007-
253A Mouse Tale$30,471111,5092015-
254Chinese Puzzle$30,460101,5102014-
255I Don't Know How She Does It$30,14281,5162011Italian International Film
256Code Name: Geronimo$30,12981,5172012-
257Setup$29,998181,5202011-
258The Water Horse$29,946131,5222008-
259Alpha and Omega$29,93591,5232010-
260The Fourth Kind$29,85781,5242010-
261The Buried Secret$29,847101,5252015-
262Splice
2010 Re-release
$29,81761,5262010-
263Stone$29,69271,5292010-
264ATM$29,55861,5312012-
265Ronal the Barbarian$29,54591,5322012Prime Pictures
266Rio, I Love You$29,50981,5332014-
267The Incredible Burt Wonderstone$29,50471,5342013Warner Bros.
268A Separation$29,435131,5372012-
269Here Comes the Rain$29,432151,5382011-
270Awake$29,40261,5402008-
271The Woman in Black 2: Angel of Death$29,295101,5422015-
272The Last Legion$29,23591,5432007-
273Barbie in Princess Power$29,231101,5442015-
274The Butler$29,155101,5452014-
275It Follows$29,04061,5472015-
276Our Brand Is Crisis$29,03471,5482016Warner Bros.
277Anessa Mommy$28,94291,5502012Prime Pictures
278Man of Tai Chi$28,87171,5512013United International Pictures
27912 Rounds$28,84471,553200920th Century Fox International
280Obsessed$28,722101,5582009Sony Pictures Releasing
281A Turtle's Tale: Sammy's Adventures$28,715101,5592011-
282House$28,70391,5602009Prime Pictures
283Push$28,56871,5612009Jaguar Film International Distribution
284Misconduct$28,541101,5622016-
285Elegy$28,47261,5662008-
286ParaNorman$28,386101,5692012United International Pictures
287The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones$28,37471,5702013Jaguar Film International Distribution
288The Visit$28,25981,5712015United International Pictures
289Vehicle 19$28,21861,5732013-
290Life's Speed Bump$28,143151,5752007-
291Slaughter$28,01161,5762009Italian International Film
292Fly Me to the Moon 3D$27,96491,5782009-
293Nanny McPhee$27,89261,5802006-
294War Horse$27,75691,5822012Walt Disney Pictures
295Khumba$27,657161,5852014-
296The Bank Job$27,65461,5862008-
297Halloween$27,621141,5872007-
29812 Angry Lebanese: The Documentary$27,41581,5912010-
299A Turtle's Tale 2: Sammy's Escape from Paradise$27,35571,5922012-
300The Criminal$27,16491,5952009-
301L'Apprenti Pere Noel 2$27,13881,5972013-
302Heidi$27,004121,5992015-
303The Best Man Holiday$26,78271,6022013United International Pictures
304Big Game$26,58861,6042015-
305The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel$26,55161,605201220th Century Fox International
306Grudge Match$26,523101,6062013Warner Bros.
307Red Cliff$26,41981,6082009Jaguar Film International Distribution
308Traitor$26,39691,6112009-
309The Chef$26,391101,6122012-
310Underdogs$26,37671,6132015Eagle Pictures
311One Missed Call$26,19171,6152008-
312Horton Hears a Who!$26,02491,6162008-
313The Long Weekend
2008 Re-release
$25,89991,6172008-
314Kill the Messenger$25,82761,6212014Italian International Film
315Alex Cross$25,78261,6222012-
316Project Almanac$25,73891,6232015United International Pictures
317Red Lights$25,66781,6252012-
318End of Watch$25,49981,6292012-
319The Hurt Locker$25,49091,6302010-
320Halloween II$25,48491,6312009Italian International Film
321127 Hours$25,43891,633201120th Century Fox International
322Eastern Promises$25,286101,6352008-
323Bridge to Terabithia$25,181101,6372007-
324The Lazarus Effect$24,95081,6392015Eagle Pictures
325The Number 23$24,896111,6412007-
326Les Lyonnais$24,87371,6422012-
327Knock Knock$24,80671,6432015-
328The Flight Before Christmas$24,76091,6442008-
329Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close$24,70061,6452012Warner Bros.
330Volver$24,66171,6462007-
331The Snow Queen$24,65961,6472013-
332Outlander$24,54681,6512009-
333The Grudge 3$24,540101,6522010-
334And So It Goes$24,49291,6552014-
335Far from the Madding Crowd$24,37561,657201520th Century Fox International
336Trance$24,33681,660201320th Century Fox International
337Fame$24,33371,6612009Jaguar Film International Distribution
338Hitchcock$24,31461,662201320th Century Fox International
3395 Days of War$24,26671,6632012-
340It's Alive$24,26181,6642009Italian International Film
341The Beguiled$24,22091,6662017Universal Pictures International (UPI)
342Ricki and the Flash$24,17371,6672015Sony Pictures Releasing
343Underdog$24,129111,6702007-
344Resident Evil: Extinction$24,12271,6712007-
345The Woman in the Fifth$24,07681,6742012-
346Void$24,035131,6752014-
347Deception$23,94891,6782008-
348The Right Kind of Wrong$23,94481,6792014-
349Blood and Chocolate$23,93261,6802007-
350Watchmen$23,93081,6812009-
351Paradise Now$23,90761,6822006-
352Justin Bieber's Believe$23,874111,6832013-
353Pride and Glory$23,833111,6842009-
354Danny Collins$23,71081,6862015Jaguar Film International Distribution
355Inhale$23,64261,6882011Prime Pictures
356Winnie the Pooh$23,63591,6892011Walt Disney Pictures
357True Grit$23,39771,6952011United International Pictures
358Sinister 2$23,32171,6972015-
359My Week with Marilyn$23,130101,6982012Italian International Film
360The Ward$22,99881,6992011Italian International Film
361Good People$22,978101,7002014-
362Room$22,97291,7012016Italian International Film
363Lions for Lambs$22,940101,7022007-
364Top Cat$22,93791,7032013-
365Meet Bill$22,93081,7042008-
366A Good Night$22,707151,7062011-
367From Within$22,689111,7072009Prime Pictures
368Don't Tell Me the Boy Was Mad$22,580201,7102015-
369Evening$22,561101,7112007-
370Eddie the Eagle$22,46161,712201620th Century Fox International
371Asfouri$22,42691,7132013-
372Two Days in New York$22,40361,7142012-
373The True Story of Puss'N Boots$22,39391,7152011-
374Material Girls$22,18181,7162007-
375The Drop$22,15261,717201420th Century Fox International
376Accepted$22,009221,7182007-
377Third Person$21,98971,7192014-
378Two Mothers$21,98761,7202013-
379The Last House on the Left$21,79781,7212009-
380Black or White$21,67491,7242015-
381Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace
2012 3D Release
$21,64110480201220th Century Fox International
382Bel Ami$21,62591,7252012-
383The Apparition$21,61361,7272012Warner Bros.
384Rock the Casbah$21,599241,7282014-
385Devil's Due$21,590191,729201420th Century Fox International
386Pixies$21,58391,7302015Italian International Film
387Surf's Up$21,57571,7312007-
388Unfriended$21,56361,7322015United International Pictures
389Joe$21,538151,7342014-
390Jane Eyre$21,52571,7352011Italian International Film
391The Messengers$21,48091,7372007-
392Le père Noël$21,36491,7392014-
393Miss You Already$21,329111,7402015-
394A Walk in the Woods$21,27781,7422015-
395Iron Sky$21,27471,7432012-
396Genghis Khan: To the Ends of the Earth and Sea$21,250101,7442009-
397Magic Mike XXL$21,13781,7472015Warner Bros.
3983096 Tage$21,09261,7492013Jaguar Film International Distribution
399Chasing Mavericks$21,00891,7502012Jaguar Film International Distribution
400Open Season 2$20,839231,7522008-