| Rank | Movie Title (click to view) | Studio | Total Gross / Theaters | Opening / Theaters | Open |
| 1 | City Island | Anch. | $6,671,036 | 269 | $32,001 | 2 | 3/19/10 |
| 2 | Solitary Man | Anch. | $4,360,548 | 177 | $94,936 | 4 | 5/21/10 |
| 3 | Kill the Irishman | Anch. | $1,188,194 | 56 | $145,430 | 5 | 3/11/11 |
| 4 | The Lords of Salem | Anch. | $1,165,882 | 354 | $642,942 | 354 | 4/19/13 |
| 5 | Seeking Justice | Anch. | $411,746 | 231 | $249,912 | 231 | 3/16/12 |
| 6 | Spread | Anch. | $250,618 | 103 | $122,948 | 103 | 8/14/09 |
| 7 | Frozen | Anch. | $246,176 | 106 | $131,395 | 106 | 2/5/10 |
| 8 | HappyThankYouMorePlease | Anch. | $216,110 | 19 | $35,063 | 2 | 3/4/11 |
| 9 | Touchback | Anch. | $204,232 | 69 | $66,998 | 50 | 4/13/12 |
| 10 | 10 Years | Anch. | $203,373 | 63 | $22,707 | 3 | 9/14/12 |
| 11 | Hatchet | Anch. | $175,281 | 93 | $100,358 | 93 | 9/7/07 |
| 12 | The Disappearance of Alice Creed | Anch. | $166,980 | 12 | $40,258 | 10 | 8/6/10 |
| 13 | High School | Anch. | $139,034 | 200 | $82,832 | 200 | 6/1/12 |
| 14 | The Grand | Anch. | $115,879 | 14 | $26,334 | 6 | 3/21/08 |
| 15 | After.Life | Anch. | $108,595 | 41 | $59,946 | 41 | 4/9/10 |
| 16 | I Spit on Your Grave | Anch. | $93,051 | 12 | $32,440 | 12 | 10/8/10 |
| 17 | Beautiful Boy | Anch. | $77,247 | 8 | $16,162 | 4 | 6/3/11 |
| 18 | No One Lives | Anch. | $71,938 | 53 | $47,800 | 53 | 5/10/13 |
| 19 | Behind the Mask: The Rise of Leslie Vernon | Anch. | $69,136 | 72 | $38,500 | 72 | 3/16/07 |
| 20 | Bart Got a Room | Anch. | $53,760 | 11 | $32,763 | 11 | 4/3/09 |
| 21 | Not Forgotten | Anch. | $53,744 | 4 | $18,468 | 4 | 5/15/09 |
| 22 | Surfer, Dude | Anch. | $52,132 | 69 | $5,971 | 1 | 9/5/08 |
| 23 | Texas Killing Fields | Anch. | $45,469 | 10 | $8,772 | 3 | 10/14/11 |
| 24 | The Slammin' Salmon | Anch. | $41,587 | 11 | $26,167 | 11 | 12/11/09 |
| 25 | Meet Monica Velour | Anch. | $33,042 | 4 | $7,438 | 2 | 4/8/11 |
| 26 | Beyond a Reasonable Doubt | Anch. | $32,917 | 5 | $17,177 | 5 | 9/11/09 |
| 27 | The Son of No One | Anch. | $30,680 | 10 | $18,015 | 10 | 11/4/11 |
| 28 | The Alphabet Killer | Anch. | $29,784 | 2 | $11,000 | 1 | 11/7/08 |
| 29 | Sex and Death 101 | Anch. | $23,624 | 6 | $13,516 | 5 | 4/4/08 |
| 30 | The Day | Anch. | $20,984 | 12 | $10,121 | 12 | 8/29/12 |
| 31 | The Open Road | Anch. | $19,716 | 14 | $13,323 | 14 | 8/28/09 |
| 32 | 5 Days of War | Anch. | $17,479 | 6 | $6,254 | 2 | 8/19/11 |
| 33 | The Education of Charlie Banks | Anch. | $15,078 | 3 | $8,538 | 3 | 3/27/09 |
| 34 | Silent Night | Anch. | $14,567 | 11 | $9,780 | 11 | 11/30/12 |
| 35 | Grace (2009) | Anch. | $8,297 | 2 | $6,174 | 2 | 8/14/09 |
| 36 | Girls Against Boys | Anch. | $7,529 | 2 | $6,111 | 2 | 2/1/13 |
| 37 | Gangster's Paradise: Jerusalema | Anch. | $7,294 | 4 | $4,958 | 4 | 6/11/10 |
| 38 | Corman's World | Anch. | $7,000 | 2 | $7,000 | 2 | 12/16/11 |
| 39 | Down the Shore | Anch. | $6,558 | 2 | $4,808 | 2 | 4/5/13 |
| 40 | Tanner Hall | Anch. | $5,073 | 5 | $2,803 | 5 | 9/9/11 |
| 41 | Pawn | Anch. | $4,141 | 1 | $2,137 | 1 | 4/19/13 |
| 42 | Vamps | Anch. | $3,361 | 1 | $548 | 1 | 11/2/12 |
| 43 | Spiral | Anch. | $3,072 | N/A | N/A | N/A | 2/8/08 |
| 44 | Lower Learning | Anch. | $2,804 | 1 | $2,550 | 1 | 10/10/08 |
| 45 | Flashbacks of a Fool | Anch. | $1,664 | 2 | $1,020 | 2 | 10/17/08 |
| 46 | The Package (2013) | Anch. | $1,469 | 1 | $1,095 | 1 | 2/15/13 |
| 47 | Officer Down | Anch. | $1,463 | 1 | $1,061 | 1 | 1/18/13 |
| Summary of 47 Movies on Chart: |
| Totals: | $16,479,344 | - | - | - | - |
| Averages: | $350,624 | - | - | - | - |
 |