‘Zack and Miri,’ ‘Changeling’ Contribute to Bleak Halloween

by Brandon Gray
Seth Rogan and Elizabeth Banks in Zack and Miri Make a Porno.

November 3, 2008

In a particularly weak Halloween weekend, High School Musical 3: Senior Year bled 64 percent yet still held onto the top spot. Halloween landed on a Friday this year and overall attendance was down around 27 percent from the last time that happened in 2003. One has to go back to 1998 to find a worse Halloween weekend.

After last weekend's one-two punch of High School Musical and Saw V, the new releases scheduled for Halloween were minor attractions. Zack and Miri Make a Porno was the highest grosser of the bunch with $10.1 million on approximately 3,100 screens at 2,735 theaters. That was a lesser opening than writer-director Kevin Smith's last ribald comedy, Clerks II, when factoring ticket-price inflation and the larger release pattern.

Unless they capture the zeitgeist with broadly relatable or bar-raising/lowering humor, comedies of Zack and Miri's ilk tend to post modest numbers theatrically but can expand their audience considerably on home video and television. Zack and Miri was too narrow in its subject matter to knock it out of the park like Knocked Up and others. It was further hampered by a television advertising campaign that not only omitted the Make a Porno part of the title but failed to state what was going on, effectively dousing cold water on the humor. It takes more than simply featuring the latest trendy comedy actor, like Seth Rogen, to rise above niche receipts or propel a Kevin Smith-directed movie beyond that $10 million plateau.

Underperforming like Zack and Miri in its nationwide launch, Changeling rang up $9.4 million on around 2,000 screens at 1,850 sites. The Clint Eastwood-directed period drama, for which both grieving mother and fighting-the-system angles were pushed in its marketing, ranks as Angelina Jolie's best start as the top-billed lead in a drama, though it was below par for Eastwood, trailing Mystic River, Flags of Our Fathers and more. Jolie has only shown signs of bankability in action and thriller movies. According to distributor Universal Pictures' exit polling, 68 percent of Changeling's audience was over 30 years old and 61 percent was female.

Also opening, The Haunting of Molly Hartley crept into 2,652 locations and mustered a meager $5.4 million. It was the widest release yet for distributor Freestyle Releasing, though it came in below their own An American Haunting. Meanwhile, RockNRolla was soft in its nationwide expansion. The British crime comedy nabbed $1.9 million at 826 spots.

• 10/27/08 - 'High School Musical' Cuts Loose with 'Saw'
• 10/27/08 - 'Fireproof' Has Best Hold, 'Max Payne' and 'W.' Flounder

2/11 Record Breaker? Some Box Office Records 'Deadpool' May Be Hunting
2/11 Updated: 'Deadpool' Targets #1 Opening Over 'How to Be Single' & 'Zoolander 2'
2/9 Warner Bros. Shifts 'Ready Player One' Away from 'Star Wars: Episode VIII'
2/7 'Kung Fu Panda 3' Tops Super Bowl Weekend; 'Hail, Caesar!' Leads Newcomers
2/6 'Star Wars: Force Awakens' First Ever to Cross $900 Million Domestically
2/4 Super Bowl Weekend Preview: 'Panda 3' Over 'Hail, Caesar!', 'Pride and Prejudice and Zombies' & 'The Choice'
> MORE: News | Features
SCHEDULE: Paramount Dates 'Transformers 5, 6 & 7'
DAILY: Thursday, 2/11 (44 tracked)
DAILY: Wednesday, 2/10 (44 tracked)
DAILY: Tuesday, 2/9 (44 tracked)
SCHEDULE: Disney Sets Sept '16 Release for 'Light Between Oceans'
New MPAA Ratings Added
SCHEDULE: WB Moves 'Ready Player One' & 'The Flash'
DAILY: Monday, 2/8 (43 tracked)
WEEKEND: Weekend Actuals, 'Kung Fu Panda 3' #1
DAILY: Friday, 'Kung Fu Panda 3' #1
ALL TIME: 'Star Wars: Force Awakens' Crosses $900M
SCHEDULE: Universal Dates 'Fast & Furious 9' & '10'
SCHEDULE: Warner Bros. Moves 'King Arthur' Movie
SCHEDULE: Universal Moves 'The Mummy'
SCHEDULE: Sony Sets New Date for Next 'Spider-Man'
SCHEDULE: Disney Moves 'Star Wars: Ep 8' and 'Pirates 5'
WEEKEND: 4-Day Weekend Actuals; 'Ride Along 2' #1
ALL TIME: 'Star Wars' Breaks All-Time Domestic Record
Chrisopher Nolan's New Movie Titled 'Dunkirk'
'Star Wars: Force Awakens' Crosses $1 Billion Worldwide